Scarr's Pizza

The Lower East Side's most-hyped pizza — and it lives up to the hype. Scarr Pimentel's organic, stone-milled slice is a serious statement about what pizza can be.

Frequently asked questions

What makes Scarr's Pizza different from other NYC pizza?

Scarr's uses stone-milled organic flour and house-made mozzarella — a commitment to quality ingredients that produces a noticeably superior slice.

What should I order at Scarr's Pizza?

The plain cheese slice and the pepperoni are both essential. The square slices are also worth trying.

Does Scarr's Pizza take reservations?

No — walk in and order at the counter. The shop is small and the line can extend down the block on weekends.

What are Scarr's Pizza's hours?

Typically open from noon until late — check their Instagram for current hours as they can vary.

Is Scarr's Pizza good for vegetarians?

Yes — the cheese slice is excellent. No meat toppings are available, so the plain slice is the vegetarian option.